Writing a paradigm
A paradigm is a short note that tells debaters how you judge. Debaters read it before the round so they can speak in a way you can follow. You do not need debate experience to write one. Say who you are, how fast you can follow, what you value, and what you will not accept. A few honest sentences help more than a long essay.
On this page
Why write one
Debaters plan each round around their judge. A paradigm gives them the facts they need: how fast to speak, how much to explain, and which arguments you know well. Without one, they have to guess. A wrong guess hurts both of you. They speak in a way you cannot follow, and you have to decide a round you did not fully understand.
Many tournaments ask judges to post a paradigm on the tournament's website or judge system. If yours does, write a short one before your first round. You can improve it later.
For the main types of paradigms (stock issues, policymaker, tabula rasa and others), see Judge paradigms. This page is about writing your own.
The four things debaters look for first
Most debaters skim a paradigm in a minute or two, often just before the round. They look for four things. Put them near the top.
- Speed. How fast can you follow? "Please speak at a normal talking pace" is clear. So is "Fast is fine if you are clear."
- Defaults. What do you do when the teams do not argue a point? For example: "If no one tells me how to weigh, I compare the size and the chance of each impact." New judges can say "I have no set defaults. Please tell me how to decide."
- Argument views. How do you feel about the big argument types: topicality, counterplans, kritiks and theory? It is fine to say "I am new to these. Explain them in plain words."
- Lines you will not cross. Rudeness, unsafe behavior, clipping (skipping words of evidence while claiming to read them), new arguments in the last speeches. Say what you will do: lower points, or report it.
Other useful parts
- Your background, in one sentence. "Parent judge, second year." "Debated four years in high school. Now a coach."
- The email chain. Whether you want to be on it, and the address to use. See Speech docs and email chains.
- How you decide. One or two sentences: "I decide from my notes of what was said, not my own views of the topic."
- Speaker points. What a typical score from you means, if you have a view.
- Disclosure. Whether you give an oral decision, when the tournament allows it.
Be honest
The most useful paradigm is an honest one. If you are new, say so. If you cannot follow fast speech, say so. If you lean one way on a big question, such as kritiks or conditionality (whether the neg may drop its counterplan later), say so, and say whether you can still be persuaded.
Do not try to sound like an expert. Debaters adapt better to a true picture than to a flattering one. A parent judge who writes "I want clear, slow speeches and a simple story" will get exactly that from good teams.
Then judge the way you wrote. If your paradigm says "slow down," but you vote for the fastest team every time, debaters stop trusting it.
Keep it short and clear
- Aim for a few short paragraphs, or a short list. A long essay buries the four key facts.
- Use plain words. Avoid inside terms unless your readers will know them.
- Put the most important line first. Speed often goes first.
- Update it once a season, or when your views change. Remove lines that are no longer true.
Two sample paradigms
Both are invented. Use them as a starting point, and change them to fit you.
A new parent judge:
Background: parent judge, first
season.
Speed: please speak at a normal
talking pace. If I cannot follow,
I will say "clear" or "slow."
How I decide: from my notes of
what you said. I do not vote on
my own views of the topic. Tell
me what the most important issue
is and why you win it.
Arguments: I am new to
topicality, counterplans and
kritiks. If you run one, explain
it in plain words and tell me
why it matters.
Lines: be respectful. I will
lower points for rudeness.
Email chain: yes, please add me
(address on my judge card).
An experienced judge. It uses terms that debaters know. A new judge does not need them.
Background: debated four years;
have judged for several seasons.
Speed: fast is fine if you are
clear. Slow down on tags, plan
texts and theory.
Defaults: I weigh offense against
offense. On topicality, I lean
toward competing interpretations
unless you argue otherwise.
Arguments: open to all styles.
Explain your framework and how I
should weigh it against the other
team's.
Evidence: I read cards only when
the teams disagree about what one
says. Explanation beats a card
read with no explanation.
Lines: for clipping, slurs or
unsafe behavior, I stop the round
and follow the tournament's
rules. New arguments in the 2NR
or 2AR will not count.
Email chain: yes (address on my
judge card).
Example in flow shorthand
How one paradigm line plays out in a round. The judge's paradigm says: "I use the weighing the teams give me. If no one weighs, I compare size and chance."
The neg runs a DA (disadvantage): a chain of steps from the plan to a bad result. "Extended" means the team kept the argument going in a later speech. "->" means "leads to".
2NR:
DA: recession -> big
conflict risk
Link card extended
(no weighing)
2AR:
Case saves lives now
(sure, smaller)
Chance first: DA chain is
long; each step only
"could"
Judge's note:
Only the aff weighed:
chance first. Neg did not
answer.
Per my paradigm, use the
aff's weighing.
DA = big, low chance.
Case = smaller, sure.
Chance first -> AFF
How to read it: only the aff weighed, so the judge used the aff's weighing (chance first), not the size-and-chance default, and voted aff.
The RFD (reason for decision) should say two things. A neg weighing argument could have changed the result. And the default would have applied if no one had weighed.
Common mistakes
- Judges: no paradigm at all. Fix: write four or five honest lines before your first round.
- Judges: a paradigm that is too long. Fix: put speed, defaults, argument views and lines at the top, in short form.
- Judges: trying to sound like an expert. Fix: describe how you really judge. Debaters adapt better to the truth.
- Judges: not judging the way you wrote. Fix: reread your paradigm before the tournament, and follow it.
- Judges: a default that overrides the debate. Fix: if the teams argue a different standard, decide that argument first. Use your default only when no one argues the point.
- Judges: an old paradigm. Fix: update it once a season.
Related pages
- Judge paradigms: the main types of paradigms and how to read one.
- Adapting to your judge: how debaters use your paradigm.
- Judging your first round: the quick start for new judges.
- The ballot and the RFD: how to decide and explain your decision.
- Speech docs and email chains: what to say about the email chain.